Pastors and Beer

I know not all pastors drink beer. But I do and here’s why.

I like beer. I once had someone tell me that I shouldn’t drink beer because beer’s a sin. But honestly, truth be told, beer’s not a sin. Cheap beer–now that’s a sin. In fact, there is not one biblical citation that demands total abstinence from alcohol; not even for pastors. (There is that little bit about some people in the Old Testament who took “Nazarite vows”; but that vow was to abstain from the “fruit of the grape”. So even a Nazarite could drink but they’d have to opt for… beer! — a non-grape beverage.)

And sure, we should be careful. But care is not the same as being goofy.

Not one culture other than 20th century American culture has ever preached the heretical doctrine of total abstinence (Okay, I’ll give you some “desert fathers” of old, but they were fringe, very fringe). It wasn’t until the rise of fundamentalism that anyone ever preached an abstinence heresy. Until then, all Christian cultures enjoyed varying forms of adult beverages, in moderation, of course. What’s more, the abstinence heresy is localized in the U.S.; it’s an American phenomenon. Or maybe we should call it what it really is: one American sub-culture’s Johnny-come-lately tradition. That is all.

One of my favorite abstinence-heretics of all time was a man by the name of Charles Welsh. In the late 1800’s (the height of American fundamentalism) Chuck invented a special kind of unfermented grape juice that he and his fellow fundies could drink in good conscience during our sacrament called Communion. We still enjoy Chuck’s grape juice to this day, it bears his name: Welch’s. I still prefer a Sonoma County merlot, but hey, to each his own.

But back to beer. Can one in good conscience seriously eat crabs or watch football without it? Not really. Not in earnest. Not with passion.

I like beer. One very powerful reason I like beer is because once you’ve tasted great Pilsners like Mr Interested’s homebrew, you can never go back to root beer. And who could forget the great ales of the ages? I’m reminded of Martin Luther and Wittenberg ale; and yes, served up warm.

So that’s one pastor’s view on beer. And I think you should let me come over to your house to watch football on your HD flat panel and drink your beer.

Invite me…

Comments (7) to “Pastors and Beer”

  1. Here’s a link to a page that discusses Luther’s attachment to beer in a little more detail:

    http://home.earthlink.net/~ggsurplus/beersluther.html

    Awesome.

  2. Here is a viewpoint from the Salvation Army:

    By far the most common drug addiction is to alcohol, and this addiction is on the increase in most parts of the world. The Salvation Army, recognizing both spiritual and temporal dangers inherent in the use of alcoholic beverages, has historically required total abstinence of its soldiers and officers. While not condemning those outside its ranks who choose to indulge, it nevertheless believes total abstinence to be the only certain guarantee against overindulgence and the evils attendant on addiction.
    While they don’t lay claim of abstinence to be in the bible, they do give good reason for their beleif.

  3. The Salvation Army shares a sound view, especially because they don’t insist that their mandate is “biblical” or even spiritual, but practical. This is especially good advice for recovering alcoholics, or those given to addictions.

    Further, the Salvation Army is a great organization that seems to understand the holistic message of the Gospel; that the Gospel is more than a mouth proclaiming a message, it’s also hands and feet demonstrating mercy through tangible service in a hurting world.

    Thank NBEHTM!

    BTW: Does your “pseudo-acro-nym” (coined, but you can use it) have anything to do with an old band called Oingo Boingo?

  4. Maybe.

    Mainly just a way for a pessimist to deal with things. Perhaps a in a little bad taste, but it is what it is.

  5. Very superior site. Good job. thnx.

  6. I am so thankful for finding your website!

  7. Well done!

Post a Comment
*Required
*Required (Never published)